Thread:RRabbit42/@comment-27006032-20181012203306/@comment-27006032-20181012214832

Thank you for taking your time to reply. What would a good compromise be?

The main advantage  of only having on wiki on the same subject would be that it would be more complete. The advantage of an "independent" wiki is that big changes to the site are (optimally) decided by the users and not the company owning the wiki. The negative side of not being a part of wikia is that the site probably gets less traffic and therefore less contributors.