“This is our pet. We can question his integrity and disposition, but we can't question his heart. Are you trying to teach us that the way to solve a problem with something we love is to throw it away?”
Bart's Dog Gets an "F" is the sixteenth episode of Season 2.
After Santa's Little Helper gets in trouble for destroying Homer's new sneakers, eating Homer's macadamia nut cookie, and tearing Marge's heirloom quilt, Bart enrolls the hound into an obedience school, which Santa's Little Helper must pass if he wants to continue being the Simpsons' pet.
The Simpsons' unintelligent dog, Santa's Little Helper, has been causing the family all sorts of problems. He doesn't obey commands, and is just constantly making a nuisance of himself.
Lisa has the mumps and has to spend a few days home from school. While Marge teaches her sewing, Homer goes to the mall to buy some magazines for her. There he sees and purchases some expensive shoes known as 'Assassins', which he saw Ned Flanders with earlier, and which Santa's Little Helper eventually destroys. Homer eventually goes to the mall's cookie shop to receive a macadamia nut cookie as well.
Marge shows Lisa a patchwork quilt which is a family heirloom. Lisa makes her own contribution to it, but then Santa's Little Helper rips it up, and Homer's cookie gets eaten. With all this done, Homer and Marge consider giving the dog away, but the kids, especially Bart, have grown to love the dog and protest to keep him. Marge tells the kids that while he is a nice dog, he chews up everything, doesn’t obey and isn’t even housebroken. She also points out, he hasn't even passed the obedience classes which they spent a lot of money on. Lisa gives a heartfelt speech before their parents reluctantly agree that they can keep the pooch if he passes obedience school.
Santa's Little Helper does not do well at the Obedience School as Bart is unwilling to use a choke chain and Santa's Little Helper still doesn't understand Bart's commands at all. In the meantime, Homer and Marge work on an ad for when they do have to sell the dog. The night before the final exam, Homer threatens that if Santa's Little Helper fails the exam, he will have to go, but Bart and Lisa are very upset about this and ask to give the dog another chance but Homer won't allow it. Bart and Santa's Little Helper play, thinking it will be their last few hours together, Bart tells the pooch if he could understand him, he would know why he has to leave. This bonding breaks down the communication barrier, allows Santa's Little Helper to understand Bart's commands, and to pass obedience school much to the family (bar Homer)'s happiness. Lisa marks the occasion by creating a new quilt to replace the one that was destroyed.