(Fade in to the front of the Springfield County Court House, where several protesters (Abe Simpson, Ned Flanders, Maude Flanders, Rod Flanders, Todd Flanders, Groundskeeper Willie (actually holding up his rake), Barney Gumble, a woman, and the same employee from the previous commercial) are holding up Butterfinger signs, camera crew, and sounds of yelling are in the background, with Scott Christian reporting the scene.)
Scott Christian: The crime of the century has been solved! We're live from Springfield to find out who laid a finger on Bart's Butterfinger!
(Cut to the same poster seen in the previous commercial, and the word "$50,000" does its animation a couple seconds later, like the previous commercial.)
Scott Christian: And, who will collect the fifty thousand dollar reward?
(Cut to Clancy Wiggum, who's signaling Eddie to wheel out the thief who stole the Butterfinger from Bart.)
Clancy Wiggum: Wheel 'em out, boys!
(The thief, who is revealed to be Krusty the Clown a couple seconds later, is disguised as Homer Simpson with a Homer mask, white polo shirt, and blue pants, although his red shoes are seen. He is in a hand truck all tied up, and is wheeled out by Eddie.)
Bart: (thinks that Homer is the thief who stole his Butterfinger.) Homer?
(We pan down to Krusty's red shoes, revealing that he is the thief who stole the Butterfinger. Maggie sees the shoes, and crawls up towards the Homer mask, who pulls it off and reveals Krusty's head while he lets out a yell after the mask gets pulled off.)
Bart: (gasps, surprised that Krusty was the one who stole his Butterfinger.) Krusty!
(Cut to a view of Clancy Wiggum, Maggie, Krusty, and Bart. Krusty is amused about stealing the Butterfinger at Bart. Chief Wiggum and Maggie are staring at Krusty.)
Krusty the Clown: Hoohoohahahaha! (Bart moans at Krusty.) Eeeuuhh. (He hops towards the courthouse entrance's stairs, due to him being tied to the hand truck, who didn't notice that the stairs are there, causing him to fall down the stairs while grunting.) Hurt! Pain! (He then face plants on the sidewalk, where the same protesters from earlier, along with Jasper and Wendell Borton, are standing in front of him.) Uuuugghhhh.
Scott Christian: That's who done it! And here's who won the fifty thousand dollar reward!
(Cut to a spinning newspaper gag. An issue of The Springfield Shopper has the headline revealing who won the fifty thousand dollar reward, who turns out to be Nancy Fredholm, a real-life resident from Hudson, New Hampshire. The headline on the newspaper says, "NANCY FREDHOLM HUDSON, NEW HAMPSHIRE WINS $50,000 REWARD!".)
Bart: Nancy Fredholm from Hudson, New Hampshire!
(Cut to Bart, wearing a fedora and trench coat, who is taking a bite of his Butterfinger, while Clancy Wiggum is wheeling out Krusty, who now has an arm sling on his right arm, a head wrap on his forehead, and his right eyelid being all puffy and swollen, which are causes for Krusty's fall down the stairs and for his face plant.)
Bart: (with his mouth full) You're one effective detective, ma'am.
(The screen fades out.)