God and St. Peter contemplate what merits a soul getting into heaven, while citizens of Springfield remember their divine encounters.
Plot[]
In Heaven, God and St. Peter discuss what should allow a soul to enter Heaven. In Springfield Sunday school class, several citizens tell spiritual stories. Ned Flanders remembers how, in his youth, he was once a young door-to-door trampoline salesman, until the static discharge of his product almost killed him and a young Homer. He cultivated his characteristic mustache to cover the scar he received on his upper lip, and converted to Christianity.
Finally, Lisa tells a gender-swapped story of Siddhārtha Gautama, founder of Buddhism. God agrees that all righteous souls should be allowed to enter Heaven, including an impacted Mr. Burns (Smithers's plus one).