Cleric first met the Shadow Knight in the game when he attacked a small village. Alf and Moe filled her in on who the Shadow Knight was; The most malicious and powerful player in the game. The Shadow Knight then killed Turkey Skinner with his flame sword. When Marge discovered he was really Bart she was shocked that he was so violent but happy that her son played the game well.
He lived in a castle with Milhouse, his helper who had been turned into a lady. He was a apparently regular customer at a tavern run by Moe.
When Cleric came to visit him, she didn't like his decorating style, much to his annoyance. In Moe's tavern in the game, the Shadow Knight asked Moe to serve him a drink made from blood wrung from the head of a pixie. He then told Moe to flog himself with a mace while reciting the goblin's code. Cleric then came into the bar and told him off for drinking, further annoying him. However, after Cleric accidentally went into the bullies' camp, the Shadow Knight saved her.
He killed Cleric when she changed one of his chambers into hello kitty, but brought her back to by donating two thirds of his Heath points, making him very weak. The other characters took advantage of this and killed him, despite his threats that if they killed him in the game he would egg their houses in reality. After his character's death, Bart gave up the game but Marge made a new character to avenge him.